Unique and Desirable Places to Stay

StayRare Rentals

Reviews

Brittiany

January 2026 · Airbnb

Everything was perfect with this stay! Jared’s home was beautiful and well furnished with all the needed amenities. Jared was very thorough with the check in and check out process! Highly recommend and would gladly stay with him again!

Jason

January 2026 · Airbnb

Can’t say enough good things about our recent stay. Had a group of coaches in for a convention at the downtown convention center. Great location with plenty of room in the house to move around. Very large kitchen where you can move around. The rain shower heads in each bathroom is a big time bonus. Thank you so much for a great stay. When in Columbus again we will be there!

Justin

January 2026 · Airbnb

Jared was a very kind and responsive Airbnb host. He answered any questions I had quickly. The Airbnb was perfect for my group, the accommodations were fantastic. The Airbnb does have thin walls, if there’s another group next door you’ll be able to hear them in the living room. Which is especially bad at 3am. But when you are in the bedrooms, you won’t be able to hear any outside noise, it is quiet and peaceful. My group enjoyed staying at this Airbnb. Thank you Jared and the rest of the team! God bless!

Brandon

January 2026 · Airbnb

Great place, easy to get to with it being right off highway. Double cabins are a plus as well and during summer ponds would be great to hang and fish out of.

Jessica

December 2025 · Airbnb

This was a wonderful place for our youth group to come for our yearly destination now getaway. The place was super nice (almost too nice for a bunch of teenagers), but we thoroughly enjoyed it. We had to go and search for firewood elsewhere for our Bible study around the fire, but there were numerous chairs for our group. Towels were provided which was nice. It will definitely stay on our radar for future trips.

Acacia

December 2025 · Airbnb

I wish we could've stayed longer! This was a perfect stay for a famoly get away. There was a lot to do at the cabin whether you wanted to stay in or explore the surroundings. It was cozy and the beautiful ponds and trees were definitely a plus. Had a fire before bed and woke up and went to 58 West, a really nice brunch place. Had lots of the cute hocking hills stores just 3 minutes down the road. Loved it! The host was extremely responsive and super nice/helpful. Hopefully we will be back soon!

Tabitha

December 2025 · Airbnb

We was in town for my daughter‘s graduation from Ohio State. The host was great. Instructions were perfectly clear straight to the point.. house was extra beautiful love the open floor plan

Lisa

December 2025 · Airbnb

House was great, only suggestion would be that bedrooms need mirrors! Plenty of bathrooms and showers but to shower and ready many people all at once it’s hard when there isn’t much mirror space, if the bedrooms all had big mirrors it would be more convenient. Overall great house for large group, we had a great time and plenty of space!

Kha-Lee

December 2025 · Airbnb

The host was very great with communication given this was the first time i used this app. the place was amazing just about all the way round suprisingly spacious despite looking like it is from the outside. Their cleaning crew is just as clear and understanding as the host. They even have old school arcade games in the attic. All in all it was a pleasure to be this host's guest and can definitely see myself paying for a couple days again.

Christy

December 2025 · Airbnb

If you’re looking for an amazing lake house, this is your place! Large house with plenty of space for your entire group. Jared thought of everything…. Forgotten toothbrush? There’s one in the drawer. Hairdryers in each bathroom. We had 25 people for my sister’s 60th birthday and never felt crowded. It’s perfect for your large group.